I remember being quite excited when I saw Tintin In America in the window of my local bookshop back in the late 70s when it was first released in English; the cover which showed an Indian Chief pointing threateningly to Tintin who was tied to a pole looked very promising. At that point I owned Crab, Crystal Balls, Prisoners and Black Gold and I'd read a few of the others, so I was expecting something along similar lines...
Well, clearly I was going to be disappointed. No Captain Haddock, Calculus or Thompsons, only the vaguest of plots... and Snowy... talks!
It was obvious really that America was a much earlier book. Actually, it's the only book that gives the date in which it's set in the first line; "Chicago, 1931, when gangster bosses ruled the city..." From then on it's easier to be a little more forgiving. It's a period piece, giving us a snapshot of a pre-war America at the time of prohibition and Al Capone. OK, there isn't much of a storyline, like the other earlier books it's a series of vignettes, most of which are either comical or completely fantastical.
However, there are some excellent sequences. I was always amazed by page 29 in particular, probably the book's finest moment. The sympathetic (for 1931) treatment of the Native Americans, their forced marching off the land by Rangers carrying rifles and the building of an entire city within hours. Only in America!
It's certainly not my favourite, but I still find it quite fun. Compare it to Picaros, his last complete book, and there is a stark contrast. Sorry for being so cryptic here, but... As Tintin gets older he gets more jaded and the world somehow becomes smaller. In America Tintin is still 'young' and the world a bigger, more 'innocent' place.
6/10 |