mct16:
I think that it is a matter of Ligne Claire being in the eye of the beholder.
That's one of looking at it, but
ligne claire is actually a set of academic "rules" defined and created by Joost Swarte in 1977, based on what he saw as the key features of Hergé's style.
I am sure I used to have something which actually laid out his rules, but I am blowed if I can find it so I will have to paraphrase, and apologies in advance if I mis-remember.
As I understand it, he proposed that lines should be of an even weight, and the only thing used to create form, thereby eliminating shading and texturization; and colour should be flat and without gradation.
It's sort of useful to have a term to give to the art of Hergé, Jacobe and others that, roughly, "look the same", but it's too often (to my mind) treated as a definitive statement of "this is how Hergé drew!", which it isn't.
I
discussed it in this post, so I won't rehearse the argument again here.