jock123 Moderator
|
#3 · Posted: 3 Oct 2010 13:04
What are the images of in each case? Are they the ones which reproduced original pen and ink artwork from the albums, or are they just the ones which show a frame from a book with a wide margin and the name of the book below?
It has to be said that the idea of the limited edition lithograph in this case is more of a marketing ploy than anything else.
Traditionally it was a concept of the fine art market, where an established artist would produce - or at the very least supervise an expert print-maker in the production of - a truly limited edition (sometimes less than a dozen, probably never more than 500) of an image, which would have been signed and numbered by the artist.
Hergé did produce editions of signed prints in his lifetime (I’m sure I’ve seen reproductions of full pages which he issued as fundraisers for the World Wildlife Fund), but there have been a slew of them issued in the years since he died, and really it’s often hard to see how they can really be worth more than any other print, poster, or image, as Hergé didn’t design them, select them, approve them, sign them, or have any involvement with the edition.
It’s not to denigrate them as decorative items in their own right, and I am as happy as the next fan to display attractive Tintin images in my home; I just would prefer it if such things could be marketed without the specious veneer of added value and collectability, and instead emphasising that the quality lies in Hergé’s image itself.
I’ve seen exhibitions which use beautiful exact copies of the original art (down to the corrections, paste-ups, doodles and coffee stains); the Fondation had them made from art they did not retain but could borrow from the current owner. If that sort of thing could be made available to the public, that might be an area where the expense of producing a reproduction might make for a limited edition which would both be an art object in it’s own right (showing Hergé at work, and the skills of the copyist), and which would grow in value.
|