Tintin Forums

Tintinologist.org Forums / Tintin news and events /

Tintinologists' Review of the Year 2005

Trivia Challenge Score Keeper
#1 · Posted: 23 Dec 2005 22:36
It hardly seems like a year since the first time I did this... I'm sure I've missed out on some things, as ever, so feel free to fill in the gaps.


In the Tintinverse, as in the world at large, 2005 was a year of both sad and disappointing lows but some worthwhile (and often surprising) highs. The year of 2004 was an exceptional one, and it was hopeful at best to predict that Tintin would receive the kind of exposure that he did for the 75th anniversary. Nonetheless January started promisingly, with the announcement that Tintin would be the subject of the Young Vic theatre company’s Christmas show: always a highly-anticipated production in theatre circles. Across the Channel the news was less good: in March the “Made in Belgium” exhibition in Brussels was prevented by Moulinsart from having a Tintin exhibit. The resulting media furore, lasting several weeks, led to the Chateau issuing an unprecedented statement claiming to have acted in Tintin’s best interests. The organisers of the exhibition, Moulinsart claimed, wanted to represent Hergé’s work with the interpretations of other artists, which they found unacceptable. This provoked a fierce denial and counter-claim, and the matter was never fully resolved, much to the annoyance of those Belgians celebrating the 175th anniversary of their independence who regard Tintin with some pride.

Meanwhile for English-speakers, there was reason to celebrate. In May came the suggestion (first made public at the World of Tintin exhibition a year before) that the English version of Tintin in the Congo was at last due to be released in its colour format on September 5th. Finally, the complete series of modern versions was to be made available. Amid the sentiments of “it’s about time” came debate abut how Egmont would handle the unfortunately outdated elements of the story that might cause offence. While we waited for the day of release Egmont published the Tintin and Snowy: album 1, an activity book for youngsters that was a significant improvement on the Tintin Games Book from many years previously. There is no indication yet as to whether there will be further books in this series (as suggested by the album 1 subtitle).

In July Moulinsart made amends for the ‘Made in Belgium’ debacle by mounting a highly-successful Tintin festival in Brussels. Events included booksellers’ markets, a rare public screening of the 1947 film Le Crabe aux Pinces d’Or, and a costume ball. There are plans to turn the festival into a regular event, providing another excuse for frequent trips to Brussels. As long as the organisers can continue to make the festival fresh and new every year, it will surely be worth repeated visits.

Back in the UK, the September 5th release date for Tintin in the Congo came and went, with the Tintin Shop confirming a week later that all books in the first print run had been damaged. This however didn’t stop a few pristine copies turning up on eBay in Belgium. In the event the delay was not serious, and the book finally reached the open market during the first week of October. Though Neil Hyslop’s handwritten script is missed, it was a worthy translation with enough wit and licence to distinguish it from the literal version in the black-and-white edition. Leslie Lonsdale-Cooper and Michael Turner’s labour of love in translating the Tintin series can now finally be said to be complete.

It is gratifying to know that Harry Thompson would have been able to see the series completed only weeks before his untimely death from cancer on November 7th, at the age of just 45. He achieved an immense amount in his short life and his exposure as a Tintinologist would have been much greater if not for the other huge demands on him as a successful entertainment producer. His 1991 book, Tintin: Hergé and his creation, had only one print run (in hardback and paperback) yet is required reading for all Tintin fans and is, despite its limitations, arguably the closest to a definitive English work. Harry Thompson is missed by many who enjoyed his work, but Tintinologists owe him a special debt for the contribution he made to the knowledge of our subject.

Despite this, the year has ended on an unexpected high thanks to the success of the Young Vic’s production, currently playing at the London Barbican until January 21st. Due to technical difficulties the original opening preview of November 29th was postponed for two days, but these appear to have been ironed out and the play has received unanimously positive reviews in the press. A visit (especially with young children) is thoroughly recommended, as is the first volume in Casterman’s Dossier Tintin series, devoted to The Black Island. Original indications were that this would be a boxset, but instead it is a beautifully-produced work allowing easy comparison between the three versions of the story, together with rare excerpts and publicity material from the original serialisation in Le Petit Vingtième.

As for what 2006 may bring: the English translation of the black-and-white version of Cigars of the Pharaoh is eighteen months overdue from its initial publication date (July 2004), and now postponed until March. Will this be the year it sees release? And if Steven Spielberg’s Tintin project is on course for release in 2007, production details and even shooting itself may begin to emerge during the coming year.


Merry Christmas everyone!

#2 · Posted: 9 Jan 2006 17:01
I must have missed this over the holidays, Ed; once again you have made a masterful précis of the Tintinological year!

The tribute to Harry Thompson is both very well put and much deserved, as is the marking of the completion of the colour canon by MT&LL-C (it is to be hoped that they will go on with the B&W volumes of course!).

Many thanks for your effort!
#3 · Posted: 9 Jan 2006 17:56
Must have missed this as well, really nice piece. Really good to look back on such a great year for Tintin! Let's hope it'll keep up into 2006

Trivia Challenge Score Keeper
#4 · Posted: 10 Jan 2006 00:45
Thanks for the comments, very kind.

I'm writing a biographical article of Harry Thompson 'the Tintinologist' that, with Irene's permission, I hope to publish on this site in the next few weeks.

Harrock n roll
#5 · Posted: 10 Jan 2006 01:04
Only spotted this today too after some forum archeology, I'm glad it's been excavated.

I'd like to add a third part harmony to the chorus of appreciation - excellent review Ed. And look forward to the Harry Thompson article!

UK Correspondent
#6 · Posted: 11 Jan 2006 23:00
Excellent review Ed, it's good to have a summary of the year to look back on. Perhaps it would be possible to have the two entries so far archived separately, maybe under the Guides?

One thing I think deserves a mention is Mats Lidström's 'Suite Tintin' for cello and piano. It was recorded in 2004 but I think it was launched proper at the Tintin Festival. It's an excellent piece that really succeeds in capturing the scenes portrayed in the books.
Trivia Challenge Score Keeper
#7 · Posted: 12 Jan 2006 16:32
Perhaps it would be possible to have the two entries so far archived separately, maybe under the Guides?

I have no objection to that at all: I'll leave it someone with the necessary powers to do so if they wish.

One thing I think deserves a mention is Mats Lidström's 'Suite Tintin' for cello and piano.

Good call Richard! I must have subconsciously put this in my mental '2004' file, as I think I first heard of it during that year. But you're right, it's a very worthy piece of work. If anyone remembers anything else please feel free to add them to this thread!

labrador road 26
#8 · Posted: 13 Jan 2006 02:20
The brand new swedish translations of the adventures reached it's destination with the publishing of Alph-Art. After some 18 months the last album was published the fall 2005. The translator Björn Wahlberg have given several interviews over the year in lots of swedish newspapers.

The new translation is a really big thing over here in Sweden. Though the older one was brilliantly done it lacked much text and was in some places quite shortened/abridged.

Please be sure to familiarize yourself with the Forum Posting Guidelines.

Disclaimer: Tintinologist.org assumes no responsibility for any content you post to the forums/web site. Staff reserve the right to remove any submitted content which they deem in breach of Tintinologist.org's Terms of Use. If you spot anything on Tintinologist.org that you think is inappropriate, please alert the moderation team. Sometimes things slip through, but we will always act swiftly to remove unauthorised material.


 Forgot password
Please log in to post. No account? Create one!