Tintin Forums

Tintin Forums / Curious about Tintin? (Non-album specific) /

End of an Era: Belgium ends its telegram service...

#1 · Posted: 6 Jan 2018 00:54 · Edited by: jock123
Something I like to remind people new to the "Tintin" books (and sometimes long-time readers too!) is that they shouldn't be read as period pieces.

It's easy to slip into a mind-set which soaks up what is now thought of as the period detail – men in hats, cars with mudguards and running-boards, traveling by sea as a matter of course, boy reporters in plus-fours and norfolk jackets – forgetting that these weren't included to make Tintin a figure from the past, but actually to show how bang-up-to-date he was.

When these stories were written, the "tech" which allowed Tintin to radio ship-to-shore, fly a monoplane, or be a passenger of a flying-boat, was as cutting edge as any James Bond thriller, and would have dazzled his young readers who would look on such things as well out of their own experience.

However, it is fair to say that the passage of time makes such a reading harder and harder for newer audiences, and what was once cutting edge quickly becomes dull and blunt. Even simple things can fox a person who simply doesn't recognize an object that once was common, or for which they may not have the vocabulary, and many of the questions raised on the forums of our site deal with issues of identification, or an explanation of why something occurs the way it does - so, for example, the "something" shown being ejected from Calculus's neck with a "pop!" in "The Castafiore Emerald" (page 9, frame 2) is a collar-stud, worn to attach a separate starched collar to his shirt... One might then have to explain *why* shirts had separate collars, and that having a collar-stud detach in such cases was a comic artist's short hand to show extreme emotion...

Telephones provide much humour in the books - but can simply confuse if you have no experience of three-figure telephone numbers in a time when numbers have become so long that one trusts in them being retained in a contacts list rather than committing them to memory, when few have landlines that they use, never mind a receiver with a dial, and since digital exchanges did away with operators and crossed-lines and most of the reasons why Hergé's calls are funny.

Now we must bid farewell to *another* telecommunications staple of the books: after 171 years of operation, the Belgian telegraph service was shut down for good on December 29th, 2017.

Integral to the action of so many of the stories - "Cigars", "Blue Lotus", "Crab", to name but three - the telegram will no longer be the bearer of orders to dispose of Tintin and Snowy, warnings that Castafiore had invited herself to stay, or, as happens so memorably in "Picaros", allow Haddock to indulge in a war of words (which surely would be a Twitter-storm in any update) with General Tapioca; and no more will an operator be subjected to the Captain's wrath by innocently asking if his message might be sent as a "Greetings Telegram".

People will soon be asking what is the Captain holding, why is Tintin looking in a large book for a telephone number, instead of swiping through his contacts, and *what* were these telegram-things that people wanted to send, and another contemporary, up-to-date scene is consigned to the pages of history.

You can read the BBC's article on the passing of an era here: Belgium ends 19th-Century telegram service
#2 · Posted: 23 Mar 2019 21:10 · Edited by: Furienna
Yes, it is very interesting how much technology have changed since the last "Tintin" was released in 1976. People have often accused "Picaros" of being Hergé's worst unintentional period piece. But I feel that you can say so about more of less every "Tintin" story, because they would indeed be up to date with current technology.

I have myself thought about how much the telephone technology has changed. In a new story, Tintin or Captain Haddock would never have to use a telephone booth. They would pick up their mobile phones. And oh yes, phones didn't even look the same way back then as they do now. Tintin would have put on Castafiore on Spotify of something similar to mute what he was saying, and not used a vinyl record. And I love your remark about how the telegram war in "Picaros" would now be a Twitter war! :D
Aryan Tiwari
#3 · Posted: 6 Apr 2019 20:18
It's sad to see this, people in the distant future might lose interest in Tintin comics since they might not find it very relatable.
#4 · Posted: 8 Apr 2019 18:29
I don't think that such a thing would happen to Tintin, but maybe I am saying this because I am a fan.

A character who already had a chance of facing such a problem was Sherlock Holmes. The 1890s are a far cry from the modern day scenario and add to that, the stark difference in the methods that police used in crime solving.But in any case, despite all the recent adaptations to try and adapt Holmes to a modern setting, he is still a very Victorian age detective and his appeal lies in that very fact. So even if Holmes is shown with a smartphone or riding a motorbike, people still read and marvel at Conan Doyle's originals set in the Victorian age because that's where he is at his best.

Similarly, Tintin is very much a twentieth century hero and he is at his best during this time frame. I don't think the popularity of Tintin is as much dependent on the passage of time as Tintin's adventures' dependence on its twentieth century time period.
#5 · Posted: 9 Apr 2019 00:42 · Edited by: snowybella
Aryan Tiwari

I don't think that that would be fully possible. Tintin's always going to have at least a few fans (but, like Shivam, I'm probably biased in my thinking!).

To take another example, there's Charles Dickens. Ever since he started publishing his stories, he was incredibly popular, and he - correctly - still is, despite the early eighteen-hundreds being completely different from ours. Many elements in, say, Great Expectations reflect the times he lived in, and so does the Tintin series. The former is a reliable first-hand source of transport, communication, everything. So is the latter.

Even if the Tintin series does lose popularity in the future (like Dickens' books), then there will always be a few people who know about him.

I guess that there will always be fans in Belgium and France.

Please be sure to familiarize yourself with the Forum Posting Guidelines.

Disclaimer: Tintinologist.org assumes no responsibility for any content you post to the forums/web site. Staff reserve the right to remove any submitted content which they deem in breach of Tintinologist.org's Terms of Use. If you spot anything on Tintinologist.org that you think is inappropriate, please alert the moderation team. Sometimes things slip through, but we will always act swiftly to remove unauthorised material.


  Forgot your password?
Please sign in to post. New here? Sign up!